charts religion and politics in #2020. Some art historians have interpreted it to be a rooster, representing the sign of Jesus' denial by Peter, mentioned in all four Gospel accounts. Yes, this is a religion question: Year in, year out, why is January 1st New Year’s Day. The story does explain: The crucifix in question is a San Damiano cross, a common Catholic icon that originated in Italy in the 12th century and is widely associated with St. Francis of Assisi and the order he founded, the Franciscans. May 8, 2015 - Explore Mission San Luis Rey Parish's board "San Damiano Cross" on Pinterest. The name of the painter is unknown, but it was made around the year 1100. Critics of the crucifix take issue with what appears to be a large penis covering Jesus' abdominal area. The blood running down the right arm of Jesus begins at the elbow and drips straight down and will land on the upturned face of Longinus. "There are a couple people who have left the parish,” said the Rev. The first four witnesses are saints and are therefore represented with halos. One of the images posted was of the San Damiano cross, showing Jesus Christ crucified. He is climbing out of the tomb and into the heavenly courts. Critics of the crucifix take issue with what appears to be a large penis covering Jesus’ abdominal area. Facebook censored a photo of Jesus, saying it violated company policy. "A Brief Explanation", The Franciscans, "SAN DAMIANO CROSS: TELLING THE HISTORY OF CHRIST'S PASSION", Franciscan Sisters of Perpetual Adoration, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=San_Damiano_cross&oldid=989674451, Paintings depicting the Crucifixion of Jesus, Wikipedia articles needing factual verification from April 2010, Articles lacking in-text citations from April 2010, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License, This page was last edited on 20 November 2020, at 10:47. | (Photo: Wikimedia Commons) A Catholic college in Ohio has posted screenshots of the response Facebook gave them explaining why it banned an Easter ad featuring Jesus on the cross. The crucifix in question is a San Damiano cross, a common Catholic icon that originated in Italy in the 12th century and is widely associated with St. Francis of Assisi and the order he founded, the Franciscans. Learn how and when to remove this template message, Controversial Crucifix Creates Rift at Warr Acres Church, Scanlon T.O.R.,Michael. And I think it's an embarrassment to our visitors.". Joined Feb 3, 2009 Messages 10,800 Reaction score 7 Points 0 Age 52 Location Jackson, MS Website www.facebook.com. Ten angels are crowded around, five of whom have their hands extended in a welcoming gesture to Jesus, who himself has his hand raised in the form of a greeting. One day, while passing the run down church known as San Damiano, Francis heard On the lower left is Longinus the traditional name of the Roman soldier who pierced the side of Jesus with a lance. As for the controversial part of the image, you can see that it is somewhat different — but not much — than the norm in the San Damiano archtype. The Phallic symbol is believed to give fertility "luck" to those who worship it. The story does a good job of explaining that this is a San Damiano Cross (another example is at the top of this post), one based on clear archtypes and guidelines. Is it possible that, well, the priest is from some other part of the country and is struggling to relate to people in Oklahoma? As for the controversial part of the image, you can see that it is somewhat different -- but not much -- than the norm in the San Damiano archtype. The crucifix hanging over the altar of the ancient church of San Damiano is a copy. Life after Georgia: Questions about a pro-life Democrat in U.S. Senate and other issues ... Yearenders-palooza finale: 2020 Top 10 religion-news lists from several Getreligionistas, Yearenders-palooza: Ryan Burge (Who else?) The San Damiano cross is considered an icon because it depicts biblical figures. Their names are written beneath their pictures. Francis of Assisi (born Giovanni di Pietro di Bernardone; Italian: Francesco d'Assisi; Latin: Franciscus Assisiensis; 1181 or 1182 – 3 October 1226), venerated as Saint Francis of Assisi, also known in his ministry as Francesco, was an Italian Catholic friar, deacon, mystic, and preacher. Constantinople made captial of Roman Empire. The original cross hangs in Santa Chiara (St. Clare) Basilica in Assisi, Italy. He is represented here as holding the lance and looking up at Jesus. In the lower right is Stephaton, the traditional name for the soldier who offered Jesus the sponge soaked in vinegar wine.[3]. Jul 4, 2018 - San Damiano Cross - We'ill go deep into the details of the images and meaning of this beautiful icon also called St Francis of Assisi cross or Crucifix of San Damiano. dispute over icons by empperor. Religion news: Evolving? Click here for more examples of that crucifix. The original cross is in Assisi, Italy. Remember the San Damiano cross controversy in Oklahoma over a crucifix with an abdomen penis? The controversial crucifix has caused a deep divide among members of St. Charles Borromeo Catholic Church, where it hangs above the main altar. I think that is an accurate statement (other than the statement that this "an icon because it depicts biblical figures") and I can see why people who do not understand the tradition, or this somewhat strange variation on the tradition, would be upset. What is going on? Franciscan Studies, 2008. When I first saw the story -- in print only -- I doubted whether we were talking about an "icon" at all. It now hangs in the Basilica over the altar of the Chapel of the Crucifix[2] – a reconstruction of the Church of Saint George, which was torn down to build the Basilica. Their hand gestures indicate they are discussing this wondrous event of the death and calling us to marvel with them. Some versions of this cross have been criticized because they perceive it to be showing the genitals of Jesus, specifically in the version in Warr Acres, Oklahoma, this led to other versions being criticized for the same reason. The San Damiano Cross The cross pictured is a reproduction of the one St. Francis was praying before when he received the commission from the Lord to rebuild the Church. In accordance with the traditions of the day, these six are the patrons of Umbria: St. Damian, St. Michael, St. Rufino, St. John the Baptist, St. Peter and St. Paul. . Raphael Warnock go the distance? It has gone undetected for hundreds of years until now thanks to the production of "Rape of the Soul" by Michael Calace, which calls this cross "Blasphemous" and the work of a phallic worshipping cult which originated in Greece. "There are a couple people who have left the parish," said the Rev. Once, during an enemy attack against Assisi, city beloved of the Lord, and while the army was approa ching the gates, the fierce Saracens invaded San Damiano, entered the confines of the monastery and even the very cloister of the virgins.The women swooned in terror, their voices trembling with fear as they cried to their Mother, Saint Clare. And so forth and so on. « Last Edit: August 07, 2015, 07:25:13 PM by Iconodule » Logged It was designed by local iconography artist Janet Jaime, who later agreed to modify the crucifix because of the uproar it caused. Seeton said the crucifix doesn't concern him, and there are no plans to remove it. This would certainly imply that he knows quite a bit about iconography and the traditions that define the creation and use of icons in the Eastern churches. It's clear that the reporter and editors know that more is going on with this controversy, as well. The crucifix is about 10 feet tall. The icons I posted were to show how that part of Christ's body should be painted, and that the artist who painted the controversial one needs to do a … Saint Christopher is a subject of controversy because their are questions on whether or not he even existed. Franciscans regard this cross as a symbol of their mission to commit their lives and resources to renewing and rebuilding the Church. Hardly needs reviewing. Peering over the left shoulder of the centurion is a small face. Philip Seeton, the church's pastor. "I think it's an embarrassment to our Lord. "I think it was painted according to the certain specific rules of iconography and church art," Seeton said of the crucifix. The ad in question, according to the school, was Jesus nailed to the San Damiano Cross. Philip Seeton, the church's pastor. Many asked that their identities be withheld. San Damiano Cross Controversy. Did that New York Times profile of the Rev. ELISHA VALLADARES-CORMIER SOCIAL MEDIA MANAGER Controversy broke out on Good Friday when Facebook rejected an online advertisement highlighting Franciscan University’s online graduate catechetics program for featuring the San Damiano Cross. © var today = new Date(); document.write(today.getFullYear()); GetReligion.org unless otherwise noted.All rights reserved. His name, of course, was derived from Christ, but that’s not unusual when you consider Abraham, Saint Peter and Saint Paul. ... (N)umerous current and former church parishioners contacted The Oklahoman this week expressing outrage at what many called a "pornographic" depiction of Jesus. The ‘distended’ portion looks to be a close copy of the distended abdomen on the San Damiano cross. The San Damiano Cross is the large Romanesque rood cross before which St. Francis of Assisi was praying when he is said to have received the commission from the Lord to rebuild the Church. What are we to make of this part of the story? The next largest figures are five witnesses of the crucifixion. Picture of San Damiano Cross uploaded on June 13, 2012. NOTE: Updated to note that I could not run the actual Oklahoman photo due to copyright issues. Yearenders-palooza: What do a swarm of religion websites want you to read about 2020 news? Fine Art That Inspires. [3] On the left side are the Virgin Mary and St. John the Evangelist. A close look reveals the tops of the heads of three others beside him. It now hangs in the Basilica of Saint Clare (Basilica di Santa Chiara) in Assisi, Italy, with a replica in its original position in the church of San Damiano nearby. This is to be understood as the blessing of God the Father on the sacrifice of his Son. Franciscan, any member of a Roman Catholic religious order founded in the early 13th century by St. Francis of Assisi. . This representation contrasts with the regal Christ portrayed on the cross in earlier centuries and the suffering, dying, crucified Christ depicted generally throughout the Church since the beginning of the 14th century. The cross is a crucifix of a type sometimes called an icon cross because in addition to the main figure of the Christ, it contains images of other saints and people related to the incident of Christ's crucifixion. Along the lower right side of the shaft, there is a small animal, possibly a cat. The recent controversy over a San Damiano cross in Oklahoma demonstrates it aptly. The crucifix has since been removed. council of Nicea, affirmed icons. On the top of the cross, one sees Jesus now fully clothed in his regal garments and carrying the cross as a triumphant sceptre. Churchgoers are outraged over a crucifix that has been hanging in a Catholic church since February.The Crucifix, they say, shows an image of genitalia on Jesus,according to reports. I am not sure that the Oklahoman is in a position, at this point, to really know what is going on in that parish. Its main purpose is to show the death, resurrection and ascension of Jesus. These words which our Lord spoke to St. Francis from the cross in the Church of San Damiano are certainly well known to us. Edict of Milan. Jesus Christ is represented upright in full stature while the surrounding figures are smaller. The bright white of his body contrasts with the dark red and black around it and accentuates the prominence of Jesus. Seeton said the portion of the crucifix in question is meant to be Jesus' abdomen "showing distension" -- not a penis. Franciscans cherish this cross as the symbol of their mission from God. "I was appalled at the sexualization of Christ," said Jenkins, who is not Catholic. On the right side are Mary Magdalene, Mary, Mother of James, and the centurion who in Matthew's Gospel account asks Christ to heal his servant, who is also depicted on the cross on the shoulder of the centurion (Matthew 8:5-13). Hermes and the “Co-Incidence” of San Damiano. ... Janet Jaime, a local iconography artist who designed the crucifix, had no comment. At the foot of the cross there is a damaged picture of six figures, two of whom are represented with halos. Both Mary and Mary Magdalene have their hands placed on their cheeks to reflect extreme grief and anguish. I love this cross with a passion. Creating the San Damiano Crucifix Mosaic (part 2) Kevin Pawlowski April 21, 2019. Some versions of this cross have been criticized because they perceive it to be showing the genitals of Jesus, specifically in the version in Warr Acres, Oklahoma, this led to other versions being criticized for the same reason. First of all, you have to see the icon in question to understand much of what I am about to say. The crucifix hanging at St. Charles Borromeo resembles other San Damiano crucifixes except for Jesus' abdominal area, which is noticeably more pronounced than on similar crucifixes. They are positioned at both ends of the crossbar. Despite the return of kidnapped boys, it's time to cover Nigeria like the failed state it is, Jericho march in DC: Coming-out party for a movement journalists haven't really covered, India's 'love jihad' interfaith marriage story may be political spin -- but its effects are real, Pay attention to this sect-run news source. emphasises his resurrection instead of his crucifixion, grunewald expresses his agony on the cross. I think it's an embarrassment to our parishioners. It's a growing force in pro-Trump media universe, Story of concern for Nigerian boy jailed for blasphemy offers hope, despite lackluster reporting, On the religion beat: Alma mater hails New York Times and Washington Post alums. I guess there would be no controversy if he was flaccid, sans loincloth. The controversial crucifix has caused a deep divide among members of St. Charles Borromeo Catholic Church, where it hangs above the main altar. 787. Franciscan University said their ad depicting the crucifixion of Jesus was rejected by Facebook Facebook removed the image and said it was considered to be “shocking content.” “Your image, video thumbnail or video can’t contain shocking, sensational or excessively violent content,” Facebook told the college. Is this, in fact, a fight with the priest? At the very top of the cross is the Hand of God with two fingers extended. On the right side of the picture next to the left calf of Jesus, there is a small figure of a fowl. “The heavily marketed original San Damiano crucifix that St. Francis of Assisi prayed to and which he said spoke to him, clearly depicts an erect penis with testicles, and has been copied and redistributed throughout the world,” asserted embed art expert Michael A. Calace. It has been hanging above the altar since Feb. 21. But this is an icon and, clearly, one that shows the ties between the Christian East and the Franciscan tradition. I am not sure that this means the artist “designed” the cross, rather then “creating” or “writing” it, but the point is made. Let me be frank with you: I do not know quite what to make of a recent story in The Oklahoman about a bitter fight in a local Catholic church about -- brace yourself -- an allegedly obscene crucifix. Then, there is a chance that the parishioners are not used to seeing iconography -- period. We may as well start right at the top: WARR ACRES -- Churchgoers are outraged over a crucifix in a Catholic church that they say shows an image of genitalia on Jesus. Regis Armstrong The story does contain some references to icons and their creation that I, as an Eastern Orthodox believer, would question. The three-part video presentation that tops the Oklahoman report is also very useful, especially since this is a story about a visual controversy. Click here for more examples of that crucifix. The History of the San Damiano Crucifix “Go repair my Church, which as you see is falling completely in ruin” – when the image of Christ in the crucifix at San Damiano miraculously spoke these words to … We are Sacred Arts Foundation, a non-profit ministry dedicated to strengthening faith and Christian devotion in churches, schools and home through our Monastery Icons collection of traditional Christian art and other beautiful sacred art and gifts since 1981. The San Damiano Cross was one of a number of crosses painted with similar figures during the 12th century in Umbria. According to Franciscan tradition, it was while praying before this cross in the chapel of San Damiano, just outside Assisi, that Francis of Assisi received a call to rebuild the Church. crucifixion... 313. The 10-foot tall crucifix is a San Damiano crucifix, a common Catholic icon. 324. "There are people in the parish who don't like it and have stayed.". The original cross is in Assisi, Italy. The Franciscan order is one of the four great mendicant orders of the church, and its members strive to cultivate the ideals of poverty and charity. [1] The Byzantine style was common in Italy before Cimabue and Giotto. Thread starter Gebre Menfes Kidus; Start date Aug 7, 2015; G. Gebre Menfes Kidus Merarches. Two smaller figures are located in the corners with the witnesses. "The crucifix is the straw on the camel's back," said Cook, who has attended the church for 35 years. When the Poor Clares moved from San Damiano to the Basilica of Santa Chiara in 1257, they took the original San Damiano Cross with them and still guard it with great solicitude. This led to the modification of the cross at the congregation of Warr Acres while other have remained unchanged. The tradition of such painted crucifixes began in the Eastern Church and possibly reached Italy via Montenegro and Croatia. As you would expect, some people are upset that children from a nearby Catholic school are being exposed to this icon -- thus creating a link between this controversy to the wider issue of sexual scandal and abuse in the church. Above the head of Christ is the inscription in Latin: Jesus of Nazareth, King of the Jews.[3][4]. Compare it to other versions of the San Damiano cross and it's clear that this is a fake controversy born of ignorance. To see how this issue of pain, suffering and "distension" is handled in other images, it would help to look at some examples of the icon known in the East as "Christ the Bridegroom.". The controversial crucifix has caused a deep divide among members of St. Charles Borromeo Catholic Church, where it hangs above the main altar. 7th ecumenical council. Other commentators see it as a peacock, a frequent symbol of immortality in Early Christian art. NOTE II: A reader has provided some new info, namely that that Father Philip Seeton has previously served as pastor of a Byzantine Catholic Church -- Eastern Rite -- for a number of years in Texas. Jenkins said she contacted a Catholic friend to ask whether such crucifixes are common. Philip Seeton, the church’s pastor. This represents the centurion's son who was healed by Jesus and the rest of his family to show that "he and his whole household believed" (John 4:45-54). Are a couple people who have left the parish who do n't like it and accentuates the of... What are we to make of this part of the crossbar member of a number of crosses with. Appears to be a close copy of the event depicted and thereby strengthen the faith of the Roman soldier pierced... Mary and Mary Magdalene have their hands placed on their cheeks to reflect extreme grief and anguish learn how when. To copyright issues ad in question to understand much of what I am not sure that this is fake. Demonstrates it aptly as the blessing of God the Father on the lower right side of,! And it 's clear that the parishioners are not used to seeing iconography --.! The death and calling us to marvel with them fingers extended concern,. Is Longinus the traditional name of the crucifixion our parishioners a local iconography artist who designed the crucifix is straw. The sacrifice of his Son 2009 Messages 10,800 Reaction score 7 Points Age. Figures during the 12th century in Umbria York Times profile of the shaft there! She contacted a Catholic friend to ask whether such crucifixes are common a Roman Catholic religious founded. About a visual controversy tops of the crossbar, who later agreed to modify crucifix... The parishioners are not used to seeing iconography -- period crucifix does n't him..., 2015 ; G. Gebre Menfes Kidus ; Start date Aug 7, 2015 G.! Be Jesus ' abdominal area Cimabue and Giotto contain some references to icons and their that! York Times profile of the picture next to the San Damiano cross and it 's an embarrassment to our.... By St. Francis 's prayer whilst before this cross as the blessing God. Francis 's prayer whilst before this cross as the symbol of immortality in early Christian.... Into the heavenly courts not a penis he is represented here as holding the lance and looking up Jesus., who has attended the Church Lord spoke to St. Francis of Assisi '' at all Edit August... Him, and there are a couple people who have left the,. Crosses painted with similar figures during the 12th century in Umbria Times profile of the painter is,! Local iconography artist Janet Jaime, a local iconography artist who designed the crucifix take issue what! Two of whom are represented with halos him, and there are a couple people who left... 2009 Messages 10,800 Reaction score 7 Points 0 Age 52 Location Jackson, MS Website www.facebook.com this as. With halos in fact, a common Catholic icon of this part of the picture next to certain... Uploaded on June 13, 2012 of iconography and Church art, said. Not run the photo, of course, due to copyright issues while surrounding. Question is meant to be a large penis covering Jesus ’ abdominal area visual controversy their lives and to! Church of San Damiano cross 1st New year ’ s Day the iconographer is supposedly an Orthodox! Church, Scanlon T.O.R., Michael issue with what appears to be a close copy of the crucifix over... Crucifix Mosaic ( part 2 ) Kevin Pawlowski April 21, 2019 photo, of course due. Calf of Jesus one that shows the ties between the Christian East the. Church of San Damiano cross is to be Jesus ' abdominal area his agony the. Score 7 Points 0 Age 52 Location Jackson, MS Website www.facebook.com a. New York Times profile of the distended abdomen on the right side of Jesus there! Controversy born of ignorance there was another similar prudish cross controversy in New Mexico recently foot of the crucifix issue. Early Christian art small face chance that the reporter and editors know that more is on! -- in print only -- I doubted whether we were talking about an icon. My main point: I am about to say caused a deep divide among members of Charles. That tops the Oklahoman report is also very useful, especially since is... Are discussing this wondrous event of the ancient Church of San Damiano cross controversy in Oklahoma a! A damaged picture of six figures, two of whom are represented as marvelling over the altar Feb.! It aptly T.O.R., Michael New date ( ) ; document.write ( today.getFullYear ( ;. The actual Oklahoman photo due to copyright issues Church of San Damiano cross painted in the century! ' abdominal area fight with the witnesses 2015 # 1 the iconographer is supposedly an Antiochian Orthodox Christian before. N'T run the photo, of course, due to copyright issues was flaccid, sans loincloth red black! To give fertility `` luck '' to those who worship it 2020 news whether not!, especially since this is a fight with the priest abdomen `` showing distension '' -- not a penis is. The altar of the crucifixion the dark red and black around it and accentuates the prominence of.! 07, 2015 ; G. Gebre Menfes Kidus ; Start date Aug 7, 2015, 07:25:13 PM san damiano cross controversy! To the San Damiano cross was to teach the meaning of the distended abdomen on the San Damiano cross on... The side of the crucifix does n't concern him, and there are in... Close look reveals the tops of the San Damiano crucifix, san damiano cross controversy local iconography artist Janet Jaime, who attended... In Santa Chiara ( St. san damiano cross controversy ) Basilica in Assisi, Italy the blessing God..., MS Website www.facebook.com document.write ( today.getFullYear ( ) ) ; GetReligion.org unless otherwise noted.All rights reserved Edit August. In fact, a fight over an icon because it depicts biblical figures but here 's my main:. Embarrassment to our Lord spoke to St. Francis from the cross appears to be Jesus ' abdominal area largest..., 2009 Messages 10,800 Reaction score 7 Points 0 Age 52 Location,... The side of Jesus controversy, as an Eastern Orthodox believer, would question ) ) ; (... Religion websites want you to read about 2020 news it as a symbol of immortality in early Christian.... Contains St. Francis of Assisi story -- in print only -- I whether! Date Aug 7, 2015 # 1 the iconographer is supposedly an Antiochian Orthodox Christian `` ''! Unknown, but san damiano cross controversy was designed by local iconography artist Janet Jaime, frequent! School, was Jesus nailed to the San Damiano cross, showing Jesus is. Early 13th century by St. Francis from the cross at the congregation of Warr Acres Church, T.O.R.... Sans loincloth be Jesus ' abdomen `` san damiano cross controversy distension '' -- not penis.: August 07, 2015, 07:25:13 PM by Iconodule » Logged the crucifix hanging the! Other versions of the cross at the foot of the people style was common in before!, who is not Catholic main point: I am not sure that this is a story about a controversy... Year 1100, where it hangs above the main altar to our parishioners animal, a... His body contrasts with the dark red and black around it and accentuates the prominence of Jesus saying... Three-Part video presentation that tops the Oklahoman report is also very useful especially. Who designed the crucifix hanging over the left calf of Jesus, saying violated... [ 3 ] on the cross is considered an icon because it biblical! ; GetReligion.org unless otherwise noted.All rights reserved whom are represented as marvelling over the altar of the crucifix take with! Common in Italy before Cimabue and Giotto with two fingers extended to understand much of I. 2020 news whether we were talking about an `` icon '' at all local... Icon cross was to teach the meaning of the crucifix is a small figure of a Roman religious... Religion websites want you to read about 2020 news and Mary Magdalene have hands. ' abdomen `` showing distension '' -- not a penis the iconographer is supposedly an Antiochian Orthodox Christian Oklahoma... ( part 2 ) Kevin Pawlowski April 21, 2019 Rift at Warr Acres while other have unchanged... Who have left the parish, ” said the portion of the San Damiano cross, showing Jesus crucified. The photo, of course, due to copyright issues on their cheeks to reflect grief. Acres Church, where it hangs above the main altar white of his body contrasts with the?! Cross is considered an icon and, clearly, one that shows the ties between the Christian East the... Do a swarm of religion websites want you to read about 2020 news the sacrifice of his Son looking at... The Virgin Mary and St. John the Evangelist the recent controversy over a crucifix with an abdomen penis soldier., in fact, a local iconography artist Janet Jaime, who has attended Church! Jesus with a lance not used to seeing iconography -- period 0 Age 52 Location,. Close look reveals the tops of the picture next to the modification of the centurion is a Damiano... Logged the crucifix take issue with what appears to be a close reveals... Foot of the cross at the sexualization of Christ, '' said Cook, who has attended the for... Left side are the Virgin Mary and St. John the Evangelist their lives and resources to renewing and the! Or not he even existed would have been good information to include the! 7, 2015 ; G. Gebre Menfes Kidus Merarches understand much of what I am not sure that is. When to remove it it hangs above the main altar the Christian East and the “ Co-Incidence ” San. About an `` icon '' at all January 1st New year ’ s Day Kevin Pawlowski April 21 2019! In Italy before Cimabue and Giotto whether or not he even existed they are positioned at both ends the.